SUSAN A. BORDERS, daughter of DAVID BORDERS and SARAH H. SALYER, was born in March of 1874 in Johnson County, Kentucky, and died January 4, 1918 in Greenup County, Kentucky. She married DAVID D. MAY, son of CALEB MAY and SARAH PELPHREY, November 27, 1893. He was born about 1858 in Floyd County, Kentucky, and died January 1, 1928 in Sandsuck, Greenup County, Kentucky. David May married (1) GENOA ELLA WITTEN, daughter of WILLIAM P. WITTEN and MARY JANE DIXON, December 24, 1878 in Johnson County, Kentucky. She was born October 7, 1859 in Johnson County, Kentucky, and died January 28, 1893 in Johnson County, Kentucky.
Notes: Genoa Witten was the sister of Julia Witten.
According to Kentucky birth records, Jenoah E. Witten was born October 7, 1859 in Johnson County, Kentucky, to William P. Witten and Mary J. Dixon.
According to Kentucky marriage records, David May and Genoa Witten were married December 24, 1878 in Johnson County, Kentucky, which is where they were both living at the time.
According to Kentucky death records, David May died January 1, 1928 in Greenup County at the age of 69.
On page 56 of the 1860 census for Johnson County, Kentucky (dated June 21, 1860), Wm. Witten is listed as the head of the household for house #23, he's a farmer, born in Kentucky, and he's 23 years old. Also listed are Mary J. (born in Kentucky, age 20), Julia F. (born in Kentucky, age 5), and Jenoah E. (born in Kentucky, age 8 months).
On pages 84 & 85 of the 1860 census for Magoffin County, Kentucky (dated August 7, 1860), Caleb May is listed as the head of the household for house #580, he's a farmer, born in Kentucky, and he's 37 years old. Also listed are Sarah (born in Kentucky, age 41), Artimisy (born in Kentucky, age 15), Elly M. (born in Kentucky, age 13), James S. (born in Kentucky, age 11), William (Wm) A. (born in Kentucky, age 9), Lewis S. (born in Kentucky, age 7), Leander C. (born in Kentucky, age 5), and David (born in Kentucky, age 2).
On page 29 of the 1870 census for Paintsville in Johnson County, Kentucky (dated July 23, 1870), William Witten is listed as the head of the household for house #194, he's a farmer, born in Kentucky, and he's 32 years old. Also listed are Mary J. (born in Kentucky, age 28), Julia F. (born in Kentucky, age 12), Genoa E. (born in Kentucky, age 10), Rebecca A. (born in Kentucky, age 8), Ann (born in Kentucky, age 3), and John (born in December of 1869 in Kentucky, age 5 months).
On page 25 of the 1870 census for Precinct 1 in Magoffin County, Kentucky (dated August 25, 1870), Caleb May is listed as the head of the household for house #169, he's a farmer, born in Kentucky, and he's 47 years old. Also listed are Sarah (born in Kentucky, age 51), Wm. A. (born in Kentucky, age 19), Lewis S. (born in Kentucky, age 17), Leander C. (born in Kentucky, age 16), David (born in Kentucky, age 11), and Easter Caudill (domestic servant, born in Kentucky, age 19).
On page 2 of the 1880 census for District 126 (Precinct 8 - State Road Fork) in Magoffin County, Kentucky (dated June 2, 1880), David May is listed as the head of the household for house #9, he's a farmer, born in Kentucky, parents born in Kentucky, and he's 22 years old. Also listed are Genoa (wife, born in Kentucky, father born in Virginia, mother born in Kentucky, age 20), and Oscar (son, born in September of 1879 in Kentucky, age 8 months).
On pages 20 & 21 of the 1900 census for District 53 (Salyersville) in Magoffin County, Kentucky (dated June 11 & 12, 1900), David D. May is listed as the head of the household for house #178, he's a farmer, born in February of 1858 in Kentucky, parents born in Kentucky, married for 6 years, and he's 42 years old. Also listed are Susan A. (wife, born in March of 1874 in Kentucky, father born in Kentucky, mother born in Virginia, married for 6 years, she's given birth to 3 children and all are still living, age 26), Oscar C. (son, born in September of 1879 in Kentucky, age 20), William E. (son, born in October of 1882 in Kentucky, age 17), Lura L. (daughter, born in January of 1886 in Kentucky, age 14), Ella (daughter, born in November of 1892 in Kentucky, age 7), Gesler (son, born in September of 1894 in Kentucky, age 5), Alma (daughter, born in September of 1896 in Kentucky, age 3), and Eria (daughter, born in October of 1898 in Kentucky, age 1).
On page 8 of the 1910 census for District 76 (Magisterial District No. 8) in Greenup County, Kentucky (dated April 22, 1910), David D. May is listed as the head of the household for house #66, he's a farmer, born in Kentucky, parents born in Kentucky, 2nd marriage, married for 16 years, and he's 51 years old. Also listed are Susie (wife, born in Kentucky, parents born in Kentucky, 1st marriage, married for 16 years, she's given birth to 8 children and 6 are still living, age 38), Gesler A. (son, born in Kentucky, age 15), Alma (daughter, born in Kentucky, age 13), Erie (daughter, born in Kentucky, age 11), Ida (daughter, born in Kentucky, age 9), Clyde (son, born in Kentucky, age 5), and Clarus (daughter, born in Kentucky, age 1).
On page 13 of the 1920 census for District 71 (State Road) in Magoffin County, Kentucky (dated January 17 - 19, 1920), David D. May is listed as the head of the household for house #110, he's a farmer, widowed, born in Kentucky, parents born in Kentucky, and he's 61 years old. Also listed are Gesler (son, single, farmer, born in Kentucky, age 25), Erie (daughter, born in Kentucky, age 21), Clyde (son, born in Kentucky, age 15), Clarise (daughter, born in Kentucky, age 11), David (son, born in Kentucky, age 8), and Florence A. (daughter, born in Kentucky, age 2 years 10 months).
The children of DAVID MAY and GENOA WITTEN are:
- OSCAR CALEB MAY, b. September 1879, Kentucky.
- WILLIAM E. MAY, b. October 1882, Kentucky.
- LURA LEE MAY, b. January 12, 1886, Salyersville, Magoffin County, Kentucky, d. April 15, 1937, Ashland, Boyd County, Kentucky, buried in Ashland, Boyd County, Kentucky, m. HAMILTON PRESTON SALYER.
- GENOA ELLA MAY, b. November 22, 1892, Kentucky, d. December 17, 1940, Ashland, Boyd County, Kentucky, buried in Dixon Cemetery, Ashland, Boyd County, Kentucky, m. THURMAN PRINCE.
Notes: According to her death certificate, Genoa Ella May Prince died from a cerebral hemorrhage. Also on this certificate, her husband is listed as Thurman Prince, her parents as David May (b. Kentucky) and Genoa Whitton (b. Kentucky), and the informant as Thurman Prince of Ashland, Kentucky.
The children of SUSAN BORDERS and DAVID MAY are:
- GESLER A. MAY, b. September 1894, Kentucky.
- ALMA MAY, b. September 1896, Kentucky.
- ERIE MAY, b. October 1898, Kentucky.
- IDA MAY, b. 1901, Kentucky.
- CLYDE MAY, b. 1905, Kentucky.
- CLARISE MAY, b. 1909, Kentucky.
- DAVID MAY, b. 1912, Kentucky.
- FLORENCE A. MAY, b. 1917, Kentucky.